Best Sleep Mask, ranked by substance

Loading edition…

Sleep Mask — criteria scores by product, ranked left to right.
Criterion · priority	01Drowsy Sleep CoDrowsy Original Silk Sleep Mask$101	02Bucky40 Blinks Sleep Mask$17	03SlipContour Sleep Mask (Grape)$52	04MZOOMZOO Contoured Sleep Mask$14	05TEMPURTEMPUR® Sleep Mask$42	06MYTREXMYTREX Eye Air Sleep Mask$13	07EcosaSleep Tight Eye Mask$19	08OstrichpillowOstrichpillow Eye Mask$45
Quiet Visual FitPriority 1	9.0Attractive, padded wraparound design with a nose cutout; one independent tester found it secure and comfortable for side sleeping.	8.0Contoured molded form; Good Housekeeping noted “tons of colors and prints.”	9.0Silk, colour, packaging and purposeful contoured geometry create a coherent, understated-luxury object.	7.5Purposeful molded cups, plain fabric and an integrated adjustable strap; aesthetic assessment, not a test finding.	8.0Contoured dark-navy eye cup leaves eyelids free and the strap is adjustable; Reviewed found the shape unusual and prone to shifting.	7.5Rounded 3D eye geometry and integrated adjustable band; visual appeal is an editorial judgement.	8.0The maker specifies a slim 3D-contoured form, shaped nose piece and ergonomic fit.	7.0Contoured eye cups avoid eyelid and lash pressure, but independent reviews criticize the thick, bulky profile.
Nightly Wear RitualPriority 2	9.0The Telegraph tester continued using it after testing and described the silk as soft, breathable, and comfortable.	8.0Testers found it easy to put on and take off; deep cups avoid eye pressure.	8.0Independent testers found soft material and comfortable, secure wear; the strap is not adjustable and care is hand wash only.	8.0Independent overnight testing supports comfortable eye clearance; foam bulk and warmth are tradeoffs.	7.0Six-month Danish hands-on tester rated comfort and adjustability 5/5; other testing found nighttime shifting, discomfort and scratchiness.	7.5Soft contact scored 4.83/5 in independent testing; lying-down retention was weaker at 3.80/5.	7.023 g weight, eyelash clearance, adjustable strap and hand-wash care support routine use; owners report strap and nose-pressure issues.	7.0The adjustable closure, soft fabric, pouch, and blackout effect support routine use, but comfort varies.
Five-Year UsefulnessPriority 3	9.0Passive darkness remains useful without batteries, apps or proprietary services. A five-year physical lifespan is not established.	9.0Passive blackout object with no electronics, software or app dependency.	9.0Passive darkness remains useful without batteries, apps or proprietary services. A five-year physical lifespan is not established.	9.0Passive, standards-free darkness has no software dependency; this does not establish a five-year service life.	9.0Passive darkness remains useful without batteries, apps or proprietary services. A five-year physical lifespan is not established.	9.0Passive darkness remains useful without batteries, apps or proprietary services; five-year wear is unproven.	9.0As a passive, app-free blackout accessory, it remains useful without software or electronics; future strap and foam wear are unknown.	9.0Passive darkness remains useful without batteries, apps or proprietary services. A five-year physical lifespan is not established.
Reliable BlackoutPriority 4	9.0The Telegraph tester wrote that it "completely blocked out any and all light" during daylight and night-light testing.	8.0Good Housekeeping reported “barely any light leakage”; maker says it blocks light from all sides.	7.0Independent tests found a tiny or noticeable edge leak, so it suits ordinary sleep but is not guaranteed total blackout.	9.0Independent tests found strong light blocking from contoured foam; the seal still depends on face fit.	9.0Reviewed's floodlight lab found it extremely dark; Danish hands-on testing reported no nose-gap light leak. Correct positioning is important.	8.0Independent measured illumination was 0.01 lx; shifting remains a limitation for restless sleepers.	8.0The maker claims 100% light blocking and many owners report complete blackout, with some fit-related complaints.	9.0The manufacturer claims 100% blackout, and CNN reported immediate darkness with no gaps.
Cleanable WearPriority 5	6.5Independent washing reports conflict: one retained shape, another lost some shape in machine laundry. Hand washing is the cautious routine.	8.0Good Housekeeping found no shrinkage or damage in laundering; maker specifies hand washing.	7.0Specified hand washing and shade drying are practical but delicate; no replacement strap or foam parts were found.	6.5Hand wash in cool water; independent multi-year foam and strap longevity is not established.	6.0Manufacturer advises wiping with a damp cloth and avoiding direct water or chemicals; independent review reports hand-wash-only care.	7.0Maker permits machine washing in a laundry net; foam and strap endurance over years is unknown.	6.0The maker gives clear hand-wash instructions and provides a one-year warranty, but strap durability is uncertain.	6.5Washable construction and two-year maker warranty; an anecdotal four-month hook-and-loop failure limits durability confidence.
Weighted value	8.8/ 10	8.2/ 10	8.2/ 10	8.1/ 10	7.9/ 10	7.8/ 10	7.8/ 10	7.8/ 10

Criterion · priority

Drowsy Sleep Co Drowsy Original Silk Sleep Mask — Sleep Mask

Drowsy Sleep CoDrowsy Original Silk Sleep Mask$101

Bucky40 Blinks Sleep Mask$17

Slip Contour Sleep Mask (Grape) — Sleep Mask

SlipContour Sleep Mask (Grape)$52

MZOO MZOO Contoured Sleep Mask — Sleep Mask

MZOOMZOO Contoured Sleep Mask$14

TEMPURTEMPUR® Sleep Mask$42

MYTREX MYTREX Eye Air Sleep Mask — Sleep Mask

MYTREXMYTREX Eye Air Sleep Mask$13

EcosaSleep Tight Eye Mask$19

Ostrichpillow Ostrichpillow Eye Mask — Sleep Mask

OstrichpillowOstrichpillow Eye Mask$45

Quiet Visual FitPriority 1

9.0Attractive, padded wraparound design with a nose cutout; one independent tester found it secure and comfortable for side sleeping.

8.0Contoured molded form; Good Housekeeping noted “tons of colors and prints.”

9.0Silk, colour, packaging and purposeful contoured geometry create a coherent, understated-luxury object.

7.5Purposeful molded cups, plain fabric and an integrated adjustable strap; aesthetic assessment, not a test finding.

8.0Contoured dark-navy eye cup leaves eyelids free and the strap is adjustable; Reviewed found the shape unusual and prone to shifting.

7.5Rounded 3D eye geometry and integrated adjustable band; visual appeal is an editorial judgement.

8.0The maker specifies a slim 3D-contoured form, shaped nose piece and ergonomic fit.

7.0Contoured eye cups avoid eyelid and lash pressure, but independent reviews criticize the thick, bulky profile.

Nightly Wear RitualPriority 2

9.0The Telegraph tester continued using it after testing and described the silk as soft, breathable, and comfortable.

8.0Testers found it easy to put on and take off; deep cups avoid eye pressure.

8.0Independent testers found soft material and comfortable, secure wear; the strap is not adjustable and care is hand wash only.

8.0Independent overnight testing supports comfortable eye clearance; foam bulk and warmth are tradeoffs.

7.0Six-month Danish hands-on tester rated comfort and adjustability 5/5; other testing found nighttime shifting, discomfort and scratchiness.

7.5Soft contact scored 4.83/5 in independent testing; lying-down retention was weaker at 3.80/5.

7.023 g weight, eyelash clearance, adjustable strap and hand-wash care support routine use; owners report strap and nose-pressure issues.

7.0The adjustable closure, soft fabric, pouch, and blackout effect support routine use, but comfort varies.

Five-Year UsefulnessPriority 3

9.0Passive darkness remains useful without batteries, apps or proprietary services. A five-year physical lifespan is not established.

9.0Passive blackout object with no electronics, software or app dependency.

9.0Passive darkness remains useful without batteries, apps or proprietary services. A five-year physical lifespan is not established.

9.0Passive, standards-free darkness has no software dependency; this does not establish a five-year service life.

9.0Passive darkness remains useful without batteries, apps or proprietary services. A five-year physical lifespan is not established.

9.0Passive darkness remains useful without batteries, apps or proprietary services; five-year wear is unproven.

9.0As a passive, app-free blackout accessory, it remains useful without software or electronics; future strap and foam wear are unknown.

9.0Passive darkness remains useful without batteries, apps or proprietary services. A five-year physical lifespan is not established.

Reliable BlackoutPriority 4

9.0The Telegraph tester wrote that it "completely blocked out any and all light" during daylight and night-light testing.

8.0Good Housekeeping reported “barely any light leakage”; maker says it blocks light from all sides.

7.0Independent tests found a tiny or noticeable edge leak, so it suits ordinary sleep but is not guaranteed total blackout.

9.0Independent tests found strong light blocking from contoured foam; the seal still depends on face fit.

9.0Reviewed's floodlight lab found it extremely dark; Danish hands-on testing reported no nose-gap light leak. Correct positioning is important.

8.0Independent measured illumination was 0.01 lx; shifting remains a limitation for restless sleepers.

8.0The maker claims 100% light blocking and many owners report complete blackout, with some fit-related complaints.

9.0The manufacturer claims 100% blackout, and CNN reported immediate darkness with no gaps.

Cleanable WearPriority 5

6.5Independent washing reports conflict: one retained shape, another lost some shape in machine laundry. Hand washing is the cautious routine.

8.0Good Housekeeping found no shrinkage or damage in laundering; maker specifies hand washing.

7.0Specified hand washing and shade drying are practical but delicate; no replacement strap or foam parts were found.

6.5Hand wash in cool water; independent multi-year foam and strap longevity is not established.

6.0Manufacturer advises wiping with a damp cloth and avoiding direct water or chemicals; independent review reports hand-wash-only care.

7.0Maker permits machine washing in a laundry net; foam and strap endurance over years is unknown.

6.0The maker gives clear hand-wash instructions and provides a one-year warranty, but strap durability is uncertain.

6.5Washable construction and two-year maker warranty; an anecdotal four-month hook-and-loop failure limits durability confidence.

Weighted value

8.8/ 10

8.2/ 10

8.1/ 10

7.9/ 10

7.8/ 10